Choosing Your Combat Profession in Stardew Valley: Fighter vs. Scout

In the charming pixel world of Stardew Valley, players not only farm and build relationships but also delve into dangerous caves filled with valuable resources and menacing monsters. Choosing a combat profession is crucial for those spelunking adventures, and the game offers two primary paths: Fighter and Scout. This article explores the benefits, drawbacks, and optimal strategies for both.

The Basics

Fighter: The Reliable Powerhouse

  • Pros
  • 10% Damage Boost
  • Can unlock the +25 Extra HP at Level 10
  • Or unlock the Brute perk at Level 10 for further damage
  • Cons
  • Lack of critical hit potential compared to Scout
Fighter and its abilities
Fighter and its abilities

Scout: The Risky Gambler

  • Pros
  • 50% Increase in Critical Strike Chance
  • Can unlock the Acrobat perk at Level 10 to optimize hammer use
  • Cons
  • Low default critical hit chance
  • Multiplicative increase, not additive
Scout and its abilities
Scout and its abilities

Delving Deeper: Playstyles and Preferences

Fighter: A Stable Option for Most

The Fighter profession is generally considered more reliable due to its 10% damage boost and an extra 25 HP, which makes your forays into the mines a bit safer. For those who like using swords or favor a strong, consistent approach to combat, Fighter is the way to go.

Moreover, the extra HP and damage mean you can utilize your ring slots for other enhancements like the Iridium Band or Phoenix Ring, providing flexibility in your loadout.

Scout: A Niche but Exciting Choice

Scout offers a 50% increase in critical hit chance, making it an intriguing choice for players who enjoy a “high-risk, high-reward” gameplay style. If you prefer wielding a hammer or want to experiment with a unique approach, Scout has its merits.

See also  Stardew Valley Hammer Guide: Unleash the Power of the Galaxy!

Though the default critical hit rate is low, you can increase your chances by equipping rings like the Ruby Ring or Aquamarine Ring. However, remember that the 50% increase is multiplicative, not additive, which means it may not add as much punch as you’d like.

Optimal Weapon Choices


  • Galaxy Sword: Contrary to popular belief, this sword does not have a 50% crit chance, but it pairs well with Fighter’s damage boost.

an image showing the Galaxy Sword


  • Hammers with the Acrobat Perk: If you reach level 10 and opt for the Acrobat perk, hammers become extremely effective with reduced special move cooldowns.

hammer with the Acrobat perk

Platform Specifics

It’s worth noting that your choice may depend on the platform you’re playing on. For instance, if you’re playing on mobile and rely on automatic attack mechanics, Fighter may provide a more consistent experience.


The choice between Fighter and Scout in Stardew Valley boils down to your personal preferences and playstyle. Fighter offers a more stable, straightforward approach with increased damage and health, making it the recommended choice for most players. Scout, however, offers a change of pace and is ideal for players looking for a unique challenge or those who want to specialize in critical hits.

No matter your choice, both professions offer their own joys and challenges. So, ready your weapon, adventurer, and may your time in Stardew Valley be ever fruitful and exciting!

Stardew Valley is available on various platforms, including PC, PlayStation 4, Xbox One, Nintendo Switch, iOS, and Android.

Leave a Comment